Security

Where does your password go when you add an email account?

Some mail apps keep your login on their own servers. Why they do it, what to ask before you sign in, and where ChatInbox keeps yours.

When you add an email account to a mail app, you hand over something powerful. Your email password, or the sign-in token that stands in for it, opens your whole mailbox: every email, every receipt, and the password-reset link for nearly every other account you have.

So it’s worth knowing where the app puts it.

Why some apps keep your login on their servers

Many mail apps run servers of their own that sign in to your mailbox for you, around the clock. That’s how some of them offer instant notifications for any account, send emails later while your phone is off, or summarize your mail in the cloud. To do that, the server needs your login, and keeps it.

It isn’t a secret. It’s usually in the privacy policy, in a line about storing your credentials or processing your mail on their servers. And it isn’t necessarily careless. But it means your mailbox can be opened from somewhere other than your own devices, by a company you may know little about, and that a breach there is a breach of your email.

Questions to ask any mail app

Before you sign in, look for straight answers to these:

  1. Does the company’s server sign in to my mailbox, or only my device?
  2. Where is my password or token stored: on my device, or on their servers?
  3. Does my mail pass through their servers, for syncing, search, notifications or AI?
  4. When I remove the account, what’s left behind, and where?

If the privacy policy can’t answer these, that’s an answer too.

Where ChatInbox keeps yours

On your device, in its secure storage. Your passwords and sign-in tokens live in the Keychain of your iPhone, iPad or Mac, the same protected store the system uses for its own passwords, readable by ChatInbox alone. They never go to our servers. They don’t even sync to your own iCloud: on a new device, you sign in again.

Gmail and Outlook accounts sign in on their own page. For those, you type your password into Google’s or Microsoft’s sign-in page, never into ours. ChatInbox receives a token that lets it read and send your mail.

Your mail goes straight between your device and your mail provider. Downloading, sending, searching and sorting all happen on your device, and so does the AI, unless you choose Apple’s Private Cloud Compute for the bigger jobs, which keeps nothing. ChatInbox’s own servers never receive your email.

The app checks it’s talking to your real mail server. For accounts that sign in with a password, ChatInbox checks the server’s security certificate before it sends anything, so a fake Wi-Fi network can’t pose as your mail server and collect your password. If you run a private server with a certificate of your own, you can turn the check off for that one account.

Removing an account cleans up. Its password and tokens are deleted from the Keychain, and its downloaded emails, attachments, notifications and search entries go with it.

Tokens and app passwords, briefly

When you sign in on your provider’s own page, the app never sees your password. It gets a token instead: a key that opens only your mail, that shows up in your account’s security settings, and that you can withdraw there without changing your password everywhere else.

Other providers ask mail apps for an app-specific password. Use one wherever it’s offered. It’s a separate password that works only for mail, so if it ever leaked, your main account would stay locked, and you could cancel that one password on its own. When your provider works this way, ChatInbox shows you the steps before you sign in.

What we gave up

Keeping your login only on your devices costs something, mostly in notifications. A server that holds your password can check your mail every few seconds and tell your phone the instant something arrives. We can’t, because we chose not to hold it. How ChatInbox still gets new-mail alerts to you is a story of its own: New-mail alerts without handing over your login.

What does sync between your devices, like your tags, snoozes, templates and rules, travels through your own iCloud account, which we can’t read.

ChatInbox is a mail app for iPhone, iPad and Mac. Download it free on the App Store