Privacy

Who knows when you open an email?

Many emails report back the moment you open them. What senders learn, and what ChatInbox does about it.

You open a newsletter, a sales email or a message from someone you’ve never heard of. Somewhere, a server notes the time.

Most marketing email, and plenty of email that looks personal, carries a tracking pixel: a picture too small to see, often a single dot, at an address made just for you. When your mail app shows the email, it downloads that picture, and the download is the report.

What the sender learns

From that one download, the sender’s server can tell:

  • That you opened it, and exactly when.
  • Every time you open it again. Read it on the bus and again at your desk, and they see both.
  • Roughly where you are. Your network address points to your town, or to your company’s network.
  • What you read it on: the kind of device, and the app.

Links do the same. Many links in marketing email carry a tag that ties a click to you. Sales tools use the trick on one-to-one email too, so a salesperson can see you opened their message three times this morning and call while it’s on your mind.

None of this shows on your screen. The email looks the same either way.

Why senders do it

Mostly for numbers. Open rates tell a newsletter which subject lines work and when to send. A shop sends a second, louder email to the people who opened the first and didn’t buy. A salesperson follows up while you’re still thinking about it. And a spammer learns the most valuable thing of all: that your address is real and read, which makes it worth more on the next list.

Most of it isn’t sinister. But you never agreed to it, it happens every time you open an email, and you can’t see it happen.

What ChatInbox does by default

Tracking pixels are removed before the email is shown. ChatInbox recognizes them two ways: by the addresses of known tracking services, and by their shape, a picture drawn as a dot no one could see. Each is replaced with a blank of the same size, so the email’s layout doesn’t move, and it’s never downloaded, not even when you tap “Load images”.

You can see what was removed. An email that had trackers says so on the line under it, for example “2 trackers removed”. Tap it to see which companies they would have reported to, and what was kept from them. The Privacy Report in Settings adds up your week.

The pictures you want still load, through the app. Logos, photos and product shots appear as usual, but ChatInbox fetches them itself instead of letting the email do it. It sends no cookies, and to the sender it looks like any ordinary browser. It also keeps a copy, so opening the same email again downloads nothing: to the sender, two reads look like one.

Spam never loads anything. Neither does mail from a sender you’ve blocked, whatever your settings.

Links lose their tracking tags. When you click a link, ChatInbox strips the tags that track you, and when a link only bounces you through a tracking address on the way to the real page, it opens the real page directly.

If you want more

The default is “Load images, block trackers”. Settings › Privacy has two more:

  • Ask first holds every picture until you tap “Load images”, except in mail from people you’ve written to, have in your contacts, or have chosen to always load. Use it if you’d rather no sender’s server hear from your device unless you decide.
  • Load everything loads every picture the email asks for, trackers included. Few people need it.

What it can’t do

When a picture loads, the server it comes from still sees your network address, the same as when you visit any website. That’s what “Ask first” is for.

We also don’t pass your pictures through a server of our own to hide that address. It sounds safer, but every picture in every email you open would then go through our company, along with the addresses that identify you. We would become the one place that knows who opened what. ChatInbox keeps your mail between your device and your mail provider, and your pictures between your device and the sender. None of it passes through us.

A habit worth keeping, in any app

If an email you weren’t expecting wants you to click, go to the company’s website yourself instead. It’s the best defense against phishing, and it leaves the tracking link unclicked.

ChatInbox is a mail app for iPhone, iPad and Mac. Download it free on the App Store