Notifications

New-mail alerts without handing over your login

How ChatInbox tells you about new mail without any server holding your password, and the honest trade-off that comes with it.

An app that isn’t open on your iPhone can’t check your mail. Something outside the phone has to notice the new email and wake it. How a mail app arranges that says a lot about how it treats your account.

The usual way

The simplest way to deliver instant alerts is to let a server do the checking. The app’s company keeps your password or sign-in token on its servers, which stay connected to your mailbox day and night. When an email arrives, the server reads it and sends your phone a notification, often with the sender and the first line already filled in.

It works well. It also means a company’s server can open your mailbox whenever it likes, and reads the start of every email you receive in order to tell you about it.

What ChatInbox does instead

No ChatInbox server ever holds your password or a token for your mailbox. Here’s how alerts still reach you.

Gmail and Outlook accounts can send a signal when your mailbox changes. That signal goes to a small relay we run, and it says only that the mailbox changed. There is no email in it: no sender, no subject, no words. The relay then sends your iPhone a silent push that means “check your mail”. Your iPhone wakes, signs in with the login it keeps in its own secure storage, downloads what’s new, and builds the notification itself: who it’s from, the subject, the first line, their picture. The relay never sees any of it.

Other accounts, such as one at your company or on your own domain, have no way to send a signal without a login, so ChatInbox doesn’t pretend. Your iPhone checks for new mail whenever iOS gives it time in the background, and stays connected while the app is open.

On a Mac, none of this is needed. While ChatInbox is running, it stays connected to your mail and tells you the moment an email arrives.

You can switch the relay off. Settings › Notifications › Wake This iPhone for New Mail. Your device is then forgotten by the relay, and your iPhone checks on its own.

The honest trade-off

A silent push isn’t a notification. It asks iOS to wake the app, and iOS decides when, depending on how much battery and data it wants to save; Apple’s own guidance is two or three an hour. In Low Power Mode, with Background App Refresh turned off, or after you swipe the app away in the app switcher, it may not come at all. A busy Gmail mailbox uses up its share sooner, because Gmail signals every change, even reading an email on your computer.

So on an iPhone, ChatInbox sometimes finds an email several minutes after it arrived. We decided that late was better than holding your login. What we did instead is make late quieter:

  • An email found within 10 minutes of arriving gets a normal notification.
  • One found later still gets one if it’s from a person and you haven’t already read it somewhere else. It says when the email came in, for example “came in 3:46 AM”, so it doesn’t pretend to be new, and it never breaks through a Focus.
  • Newsletters and other automated mail found late don’t notify at all. They wait in your list, counted.
  • Each conversation gets one notification that updates, not a new one for every email.

When an alert does arrive, it’s built from the email your iPhone just downloaded: the sender’s picture, the subject and the first words, and for a sign-in email, the code in it. Because it’s made on your device, it can say exactly what the email says without anyone else having read it.

If your alerts seem late

  • Check that Background App Refresh is on for ChatInbox, in the iPhone’s Settings › General › Background App Refresh.
  • Leave ChatInbox in the app switcher. Swiping it away tells iOS you don’t want it running, so iOS won’t wake it.
  • Expect fewer wake-ups in Low Power Mode, when iOS holds them back to save battery.
  • Make sure notifications are allowed for ChatInbox, and that a Focus isn’t holding them.

The difference, side by side

  • Where your login lives: on your devices, not on a server.
  • What our server learns: that a mailbox changed. Never what arrived.
  • Who builds the notification: your own device, after it downloads the email.
  • The cost: on an iPhone, an alert can arrive a few minutes late. On a Mac, it doesn’t.

ChatInbox is a mail app for iPhone, iPad and Mac. Download it free on the App Store